A recent
student presented me a case that had been proposed by a defender of evolution in a discussion, is another of the thousands of stories of "mutations", adaptations and natural selection that we usually find. The issue was the follower, because the student transcribe literally made me the written consultation:
"crickets Kauai, an island in the Hawaiian islands, are undergoing rapid change is depriving them of their ability to" cri- cri. " Apparently, a fly males located by their song and introduces them their larvae, which then grow inside the poor cricket and kill him.
A "mutation" that prevents the development apparatus of normal males have in the wings. Crickets bearers of this "mutation" with wings flat and are unable to produce its distinctive sound when rubbed. "Mutation" was very bad before because the males attract females by singing, and an individual without "cri-cri" could not wait too long reproductive success. But if a male does not "sing", parasitic flies can not locate it.
The "mutation wings smooth, support survival, but to be favored by natural selection, should also allow playback. How they have managed the males 'dumb' for mate?. According to the researchers "?, Seemingly intelligent behavior has saved them: the males 'dumb' are located near the few males who can still" sing "and" assault "females who are attracted by the sexual signal of poor singing . As the crickets that go extinct in this island first can do "cri-cri" and then dumb. " Grillo
common image: http://recuerdosdecabezondelasal.files.wordpress.com
"crickets Kauai, an island in the Hawaiian islands, are undergoing rapid change is depriving them of their ability to" cri- cri. " Apparently, a fly males located by their song and introduces them their larvae, which then grow inside the poor cricket and kill him.
A "mutation" that prevents the development apparatus of normal males have in the wings. Crickets bearers of this "mutation" with wings flat and are unable to produce its distinctive sound when rubbed. "Mutation" was very bad before because the males attract females by singing, and an individual without "cri-cri" could not wait too long reproductive success. But if a male does not "sing", parasitic flies can not locate it.
The "mutation wings smooth, support survival, but to be favored by natural selection, should also allow playback. How they have managed the males 'dumb' for mate?. According to the researchers "?, Seemingly intelligent behavior has saved them: the males 'dumb' are located near the few males who can still" sing "and" assault "females who are attracted by the sexual signal of poor singing . As the crickets that go extinct in this island first can do "cri-cri" and then dumb. " Grillo
common image: http://recuerdosdecabezondelasal.files.wordpress.com
In the books of evolution and sociobiology, there are millions of stories like this, but have a problem, belong to the genre of science fiction. Even assuming that what is really happening in that story is told of crickets, so it can be taken as scientific evidence of evolution, would prove seriously:
- That for thousands of years, not live on that island, flies, crickets "singers" and the crickets' dumb. "
- That in the genome of cricket "mute" there is a mutation responsible for ensuring that their wings do not produce sound.
- That the flies are blind, because if not also attack the cricket "dumb" to approach the singer.
- That the cricket "mute" has the "spirit of the rapist" is attributed, as is usually the female who chooses the male that mates.
- The duration of mating of cricket "singer" with the female for several days, in order to justify that cricket will die before "consumption" because of the development of fly larvae in their body (this is so absurd laughable, but it is essential, since otherwise be reproduced normally and die within a few days, something must die crickets).
- What did the cricket "dumb" to have children before "invented" this method the assault. Or at least show that the spirit of assault is imposed for the same mutation.
- that the offspring of cricket "dumb" can do "cri-cri."
- Etc.
I made this same criticism could have done others, but for the seriousness of this issue and give you an idea of \u200b\u200bthe weakness of the evolutionist claims, that's enough.
Semogil June 4, 2010
0 comments:
Post a Comment